Classic Reviews: One From the Vaults ‘No Way to Treat a Lady’ (1968)

Jack Smight’s movie adaptation of William (Butch Cassidy) Goldman’s blackly comic serial killer novel No Way to Treat a Lady is quirky fun, and is in some ways ahead of its time.


No Way To Treat A Lady (1968) – Rod Steiger & George Segal CRIME/THRILLER  MOVIE REVIEW - SCARED STIFF REVIEWS

Sylvia Poppie (Doris Roberts): Is that one of your own wigs you’re wearing?
Christopher Gill (Rod Steiger): You don’t look like Cleopatra, honey.
Belle Poppie: Don’t raise your voice!
Sylvia Poppie: You homo.
Christopher Gill: Doesn’t mean you’re a bad person.


Released in the era of The Boston Strangler and the Manson Family, some may regard a picture that riffs on Rod Steiger’s hammy multiple disguise-wearing granny killer Christopher Gill and his pursuit by detective ‘Mo’ (oh yes) Maurice Brummel (George Segal) as frivolous.


No Way to Treat a Lady (3/8) Movie CLIP - Goodbye Mrs. Himmel (1968) HD


And they’d be right, but it doesn’t stop the movie being a fun ride, especially when Brummell’s new love interest is the cute Lee Remick as bohemian Kate Palmer, who glimpsed Gill, who proceeds to win over Brummell’s overbearing  stereotypical Jewish mother (Eileen Heckart – much older readers may remember her from The Mary Tyler Moore Show) by claiming that she will be converting to Judaism –  and by pretending to dominate Mo.



Which apparently Jewish moms like. Or used to, at any rate.



Look out for Murray Hamilton (the mayor in Jaws) and Everybody Loves Raymond‘s Doris Roberts amongst the cast.


Lastly…as a treat, this great sequence from the previous year’s The President’s Analyst, a satire with James Coburn as POTUS’s shrink, who thinks he’s cracking up from the stress of keeping it schtum.


Not that great a picture, but a lovely scene, one which reminds me of Manhattan in late Autumn…



The President's Analyst 1967 song Look Up [Joy to the World] by Lalo Schifrin


Avatar photo

Stephen Arnell

Culture Comment Content Provider. Portrait courtesy of artist Darren Coffield. 'Non satis me tempo'