September Comic Sales – Any Candidates for Cancellation?

by Chris Braly


And it’s already time for the September numbers! And this time around – Marvel’s all-new number one issue has taken the top spot and staved off this summer’s losses resulting in Marvel’s September beating its previous September by 14%, thanks in large part to Marvel Legacy #1 moving more than 298,000 copies. 2017 has been a year in which comics and graphic novel orders had been down 10% in the Direct Market, but Legacy has become the top-seller of 2017 thus far, beating out last month’s new leader, Dark Nights: Metal #1; the second issue of that came in second place with nearly 150,000 copies shipped. It seems positive that we’re getting new entries atop the top-sellers for 2017 list; again, better than the alternative. It’ll be interesting to see how Legacy shakes up that list in October once the event is fully underway and people understand that it’s no ‘Rebirth‘.

Let’s have a quick look at the top ten comics for the month. Batman and DC Comics still dominate the Top Ten, sharing space with a few Big Events:

1. Marvel Legacy #1 = 298,242
2. Dark Nights Metal #2 = 149,487
3. Venomverse #1 = 105,398
4. Batman #30 = 100,083
5. Batman #31 = 98,594
6. Harley Quinn Ann Special = 97,211
7. Action Comics #987 (Lenticular 71,550 + Regular 25,317) = 96,867
8. Walking Dead #171 = 84,239
9. Batman The Red Death #1 = 81,904
10.Batman Murder Machine #1 = 78,202

Four books sold over 100,000 copies; Batman maintain his grip on the top ten with 6 bat-related titles selling a combined total of over 600,000+ copies, but Marvel Legacy trounces everyone else, nearly hitting 300K copies with a $6 number one issue! Walking Dead still continues to be a strong performer for Image. Our bottom six this month is more of the same, but with a few new titles.

A brief explanation of the following data: the number in parenthesis is the actual ranking on the month’s Top 300 sales charts; the first percentage quote is the drop (or rise) in sales from the previous issue, and the second percentage quote is the movement over six months (or, if the book has been around for less that that time, since the first issue).

Here’s the raw data for the Top Six Losers at DC for September:

1 Scooby-Doo Where Are You #85 (295) 4,209 +10.3% -4.7%
2 Scooby-Doo Team-Up #30 (238) 5,760 -1.0% -17.1%
3 Shade The Changing Girl #12 (221) 7,640 -5.0% -22.3%
4 Mother Panic #11 (216 ) 8,019 -6.7% -28.1%
5 Cave Carson Has a Cybernetic Eye #12 (214 ) 8,050 -2.2% -26%
6 Astro City #47 (194 ) 9,246 +1.1% -0.7%

All of these books is below DC’s “cancellation point” (which we once considered to be 10,000 copies); the poorest selling of the six is still Scooby-Doo titles, which are likely safe for the time being. Not sure how much longer Young Animal line is going to be allowed to survive with these kinds of numbers in its first year, but new titles were announced at NYCC, so we’ll see. I just don’t think this line has the staying power of Vertigo. Astro City, however, seems to have plateaued at it’s sweet spot, just shy of 10k.

We’ll see what the future holds. If we dismiss the Young Animal line and look strictly at DC Universe proper (legacy characters, etc) the 6 worst sellers are (from worst to best) Cyborg (10,385), Blue Beetle (10,879), New Superman (12,431), Superwoman (13,343), Injustice 2 (9 & 10), and Bombshells United (14,388).
None of the DC/Young Animal titles listed above are announced to be cancelled or ending.


Meanwhile, over at Marvel, where things are only slightly better:

1 Zombies Assemble 2 #2 (235) 6,255 -39.6% N/A
2 Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur #23 (224) 7,153 -1.0% -10.2%
3 Guardians of the Galaxy Telltale Series #3 (215) 8,030 -13.3% -41.4%
4 Nick Fury #6 (198) 8,019 -12.4% – 74.8%
5 America #7 (195) 8,050 -15.7% -66.5%
6 Unbeatable Squirrel Girl #24 (190) 9,869 -10.1% -15.5%

Zombies Assemble 2 lost over 40% of its readers from the previous month. This is only issue two, so this is strictly due to pre-orders. Moon Girl continues to baffle. This time 3 years ago, Elektra was cancelled when it was selling twice as many copies monthly. Not sure what to make of this, but its numbers hold steady, losing only 4% of its readers from last month and only 10% over the last 6 months. It’s found its audience, it’s just a very small audience. Nick Fury continues to drop like a rock, losing over a thousand copies per month with and a 74.8% decline for the past six months. I don’t think anyone really cares about James Robinson’s take on the Sam Jackson version of Nick Fury, which surprises me. Guardians has several off-shoot titles out there, all under-performing (Rocket and Groot titles are both around 12k each). This title is based on a video game series, not sure if it’s an ongoing or not. In Jim Shooter’s day, ‘America Chavez‘ is beyond close to being called DOOMED…! – but that’s another title I can’t understand why it’s still on life support. It’s losing over 1500 readers per month. Not sure it will make it to 12 issues. And everyone’s favorite rodent warrior princess, Unbeatable Squirrel Girl is still steadily losing around 1000 readers per month, but only 16.5% over the last 6 months. This may be another of the Scholastic & “digital sales!” titans we keep hearing about.

None of these titles are announced as being cancelled, although the Guardians title is based on a video game and I expect it is a limited run.

Check out the following indie title best sellers:

+ Image’s Walking Dead is still king of the indies, selling 84,239 copies this month.
+ IDW Publishing reached a height of #49 with Star Wars Adventures (Ongoing) selling 49,184 copies.
+ Valiant Entertainment peaked #87 with Bloodshot Salvation #1 by selling 28,738 copies.
+ Dark Horse reached #115 with Neil Gaiman American Gods Shadows #7 selling 20,928 copies.
+ Dynamite Entertainment hit the #127 spot with Sheena #1 selling 16,889 copies.
+ BOOM! Studios reached the #147 slot with their Mighty Morphin Power Rangers #19 selling 13,560 copies.
+ Aftershock Comics reached the #177 spot with Dark Ark #1 which sold 11,005
+ ONI Press hit the #180 spot with their strongest title, Rick & Morty #30 which sold 10,874
+ Archie Comics made it to the #197 spot with Archie #24 which sold 9,038 copies
+ Titan hit the #206 slot with Robotech #3 selling 8,288 copies.


Information here is based on numbers presented by Comichron and are direct to retailers order numbers, not sell-through to consumers.

Bleeding Fool

We cover geek news in regards to movies, television, gaming, politics, and comic books via commentary, news, videos, and ranting. While poking a bit of fun at some of the more highly revered comic book websites, we’ve decided it’s time to respond to either their boring ‘unbiased’ reporting with something a bit more nuanced and interesting, or respond to their decidedly progressive liberal politics with opinions from the libertarian and closer to the right side of the aisle. Follow us on Twitter @BleedingFool