Does the Uncanny X-Men #17 Outrage Seem… Misplaced?


I have already Β written a piece covering the X-Men story where Wolfsbane was murdered without fighting back, if at all. The writer, Matthew Rosenberg has since apologized for it, but not because he terminated Rahne Sinclair. Rather, because LGBT supporters believe his story is transphobic:



Marvel writer Matthew Rosenberg has apologized for someΒ content that’s been deemed insensitive and inciting transgender-panic in the latest issue of Uncanny X-Men.

Uncanny X-Men #17 revealed how Rahne Sinclair, the mutant Wolfsbane, died in a flashback that depicted her being accosted by a group of men in a park. After she rebuffed one of the men’s advances, the group began aggressively harassing her. After she revealed her mutant powers by briefly shifting into her werewolf-esque form, her attackerΒ insisted that she was trying “to trap normal guys”Β as they began beating her to death.

In the wake of the issue’s release, commentators atΒ Women Write About Comics,Β The BeatΒ and elsewhere said that the scene wasΒ an insensitive depiction of transmisogony that trivialized the kinds of violence that trans individuals experience in the real world.


Umm, is there any documented proof transgenders suffer violence, or that nobody can figure them out? Point: tall men who pretend to be women don’t shrink, and men’s arms are usually larger and have broader shoulders than women’s, so it’s not like they can’t be told apart. But all that aside, the reaction to this story from such leftists is most fascinating: if this story had been written over a quarter century ago, at the time Scott Lobdell wrote his heavy-handed Alpha Flight tale where Northstar’s homosexuality came to the fore in a clash with Major Maple Leaf, chances are it would’ve received huge praise for citing an allegedly severe problem with how homosexuality is received by wider society. Today, however, it appears we have a case of SJWs whoΒ don’tΒ want what they consider serious issues brought up, even in metaphorical terms. My, how the times have changed.


If anything, the scene, at the least, appears to allude to the AIDS epidemic of the past 30 years (and the Legacy Virus was Marvel’s allegory for it), with the creep who struck Rahne indirectly accusing her of trying to poison them. So it’s another classic overreaction at work. Yet this is what Rosenberg’s now apologizing for:



So this is what he sees fit to say he’s sorry for, not for terminating Rahne in the poorest of ways. And it looks likeΒ he’s got plans in storeΒ to wipe out at least 2 more X-Men, with the excuse being that they’ll be men this time, as if that makes the cliche any more justified. The point is, these X-Men killings have become to commonplace for the sake of short-term sales spikes, and have to be ground to a halt. As do these boring outrages by social justice screwballs.


Originally published here
Follow @AviGreen1 on Twitter

Avatar photo

Avi Green

Avi Green was born in Pennsylvania in 1974, and moved to Israel in 1983. He enjoyed reading comics when he was young, the first being Fantastic Four. He maintains a strong belief in the public's right to knowledge and accuracy of facts. He considers himself a conservative-style version of Clark Kent. Follow him on his blog at Four Color Media Monitor or on Twitter at @avigreen1